What's up with food safety? Could new laws hurt family farmers?

March 2010

Hey Alicia and Farm Aid folks,

Do you have any updates about the food safety legislation sitting in Congress right now? I know we have to do something about America's lousy food safety problems, but I heard this bill threatens family farmers. Is that true and if so, what can we do about it?

Thanks Farm Aid!
Jeffrey W.
Rochester, NY

Well, well, Jeffrey, funny you should ask. There have been a number of important developments on food safety legislation since the last time Hilde wrote about it and, importantly, the problem of food safety in our country has not gone away.

As I write, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) is in the middle of a massive food recall for all products containing hydrolyzed vegetable protein (HVP), a flavor enhancer used in processed foods (including soups, hot dogs, dips, dressings, and snack foods, to name a few). It was recently discovered that some HVP is contaminated with the bacteria Salmonella. While no illnesses have been reported yet, it's projected that this could be the largest food recall in U.S. history given the pervasive use of HVP in our food system.

The news is just the latest of hundreds of food safety headlines: E.coli in our spinach, melamine in our baby formula, toxic peanuts, contaminated tomatoes, the sorry list goes on. The Produce Safety Project recently reported that food-borne illnesses cost the nation a whopping $152 billion each year.[1] It is an expensive, scary, and at-times tragic issue plaguing our country.

It's a Jungle Out There
Today we have a confusing regulatory system designed without a clear strategy for ensuring food safety. In total, the responsibility of food safety oversight is shared by 15 federal agencies and is based on a tangled web of over 30 laws crafted since Upton Sinclair's famous 1906 exposé of the meatpacking industry's food safety woes, The Jungle.[2]

What's more, the quality of government enforcement has varied over time. For decades, federal agencies charged with food safety enforcement have been understaffed and underfunded. The Bush Administration was notably lax in its approach, allowing food safety enforcement to be largely left to the industry. The consequence? Whereas the 1990s saw an average of 100 food illness outbreaks each year, this rose to 350 outbreaks annually from 2001 to 2008.[3] Yikes!

Clearly, our food safety system needs a serious overhaul. But we run the risk of making things even worse if we fail to craft an approach that ensures safety in our food supply without hurting our family farmers.

Up on the Hill and Down on the Farm: The Latest on Food Safety
To date, most regulatory measures from our government have targeted the parts of the food system most at risk for pathogen contamination: food processing, handling and manufacturing. However, food safety bills recently introduced in Congress directly or indirectly affect farms and ranches—the root of our food system, but not usually the root cause of food safety breaches.

The Senate's FDA Food Safety Modernization Act (S. 510) is the latest piece of legislation creating buzz. Due for a vote on the Senate floor sometime this spring, S. 510 grants FDA stronger authority and enforcement tools and requires food processors to develop food-safety plans. These are good things. But, it also directs the FDA to adopt on-farm safety standards for fresh produce. This is potentially disastrous, depending on how it's done.

A Slippery Slope
The chief concern is that regulations will promote a one-size-fits-all approach to on-farm food safety, placing disproportionate and undue burdens on small and mid-sized producers. In effect, this caters to industrial-scale producers and food processing firms, promoting their growth, which is part of our food safety problem in the first place! At it's worst, this approach could thwart the good work of sustainable and organic farmers and serve as a formidable barrier to efforts being done around the country to develop local and regional food systems.

There is some precedent to this threat with the development of food safety measures for meat slaughtering and processing. Since the 1970's, smaller slaughterhouses struggling to keep up with increasing federal compliance costs and rules have been pushed out of business. Over time, the number of slaughterhouses and processors plummeted nationwide, favoring centralized, large-scale facilities. This consolidation reduced profits for small and mid-sized growers who faced fewer plants to choose from, growing distances over which to ship their animals, and less negotiating power over the prices they received. These producers were often turned away by USDA-inspected facilities that did not want to work with growers at smaller volumes of meet. As a consequence, the system gradually encouraged industrial livestock production.[4]

(As an aside, the most recent federal effort in meat safety that threatened small and midsized farmers, the National Animal Identification System (NAIS), was scrapped by the Obama Administration last month. This was a huge victory, as the pricey technical animal tracking devices central to NAIS's design were sure to punish smaller producers and put oodles of profits into the hands of private technology companies who worked closely with big players in the livestock industry.)[5]

There's some hope for produce growers, though. Hard work by the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition (NSAC), has made important improvements to the bill. S. 510 now requires better coordination between FDA and USDA and the creation of regulations that are flexible, scale-appropriate and respectful of farm diversity, particularly of organic producers. Any new food safety regulations should take these measures into consideration, not counteract or prohibit them.

In addition, NSAC worked to ensure the bill doesn't conflict with or duplicate existing requirements for federal conservation, environmental and organic programs. Organic and sustainable farmers and ranchers already implement a number of conservation and environmental practices that reduce the risk of pathogen contamination on their land. What's more, they refrain from using pesticides and other synthetic chemicals that pose threats to the safety of our food.

One other sign of hope: Senator Debbie Stabenow of Michigan has introduced S. 2758, the Growing Safe Food Act, as an amendment to S. 510. Stabenow's bill offers important grants for small farmers and processors to receive food-safety training and technical assistance in order to comply with new regulations.

Missing the Mark
Still, the legislation before us is far from perfect.

Particularly with the more burdensome requirements for farmers and ranchers, new food safety regulations should prioritize the highest-risk practices and crops. In addition, NSAC argues that farmers who directly market their goods should be exempt from certain on-farm regulations. Direct marketing offers a number of risk-reducing activities, including shortening the supply chain and creating transparencies with consumers.

Current regulation generally does not address these concerns. In addition, it misses the mark by ignoring some of the most worrisome on-farm practices.

The first comes in the form of concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs), also called factory farms. Microbes from animal manure, which is produced in mountainous and often dangerous quantities in large-scale CAFOs, can find their way into produce and crops fields through direct applications, runoff or contaminated waterways.

The second is the "sub-therapeutic" use of antibiotics in animal agriculture. Over 70% of all antibiotics used in the United States are fed to animals when they are not sick in order to compensate for crowded and unsanitary living conditions.[6] Over time, these practices are breeding antibiotic-resistant bacteria, linked to truly frightening public health scares, like the outbreak of MRSA (methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus) from hog CAFOs in the Midwest and tainted meat sources.[7]

These pathogen sources are puzzingly absent from the federal food safety policy framework. Part of the outrage coming from some farmers on this issue is rooted in the unfairness of legislation that ignores these threats, while placing potentially crippling burdens on the farmers doing the right thing when it comes to food safety.

What you can do
No one should have to worry that the food they eat will poison them. As Farm Aid and others have emphasized, food safety legislation shouldn't come at the expense of our nation's best farmers and ranchers. It should not be overly burdensome to family farmers, inhibit sustainable agriculture practices, place undue burden on small and mid-scale producers, or suppress local and regional food markets. In addition, it should go after the real source of on farm food safety problems.

To get involved, first I encourage you to contact your Senators and urge them to consider the following points in any food safety legislation*:

  1. directs the FDA to focus food safety standards on the riskiest on-farm activities;
  2. exempts farms selling directly to consumers and food that is clearly labeled in a way that preserves the farm's identity throughout the supply chain from traceability requirements;
  3. incorporates the Growing Safe Food Act (S. 2758), which creates a food safety training and technical assistance program for small and mid-sized producers, processors, and wholesalers.

Not sure how to begin? You can contact your Congressional Representatives through the federal government's Capitol switchboard at (202) 224-3121 or write to them by clicking here.

Secondly, tell a friend about this critical issue facing family farmers! It is an important, but not easily understood problem.

Third, you can donate to Farm Aid to fund our work on food safety, which includes the On Farm Food Safety Project, a national program offering technical assistance, food safety training and record-keeping tools for small and mid-scale farmers through the collaboration of growers, retailers, distributors, academics, nonprofits and some government officials. This is in addition to funding the good work of a number of groups working on this issue from coast to coast, including the Community Alliance with Family Farmers (CAFF), Agricultural Land-Based Training Association (ALBA), Florida Organic Growers (FOG), Pennsylvania Association for Sustainable Agriculture (PASA), and the National Sustainable Agriculture Coalition (NSAC).

Thanks for the great question, Jeffrey, and for all you readers taking the time to learn about this important issue!

- Alicia

Sources:

1. Scharff, R. L. M. (2010). Health-Related Costs from Foodborne Illness in the United States. Produce Safety Project at Georgetown University. Washington, D.C., The Pew Cheritable Trusts. March 3, 2010.

2. GAO (2010). "Revamping Federal Oversight of Food Safety." Retrieved March 5, 2010, from http://www.gao.gov/highrisk/risks/safety-security/food_safety.php.

3.Ibid.

4.Washington State Department of Agriculture (2008). Summary of Meat Processing Issues in Washington State. Olympia, WA, Washington State Department of Agriculture.

5.Food and Water Watch (2009). The Bottom Line of Trading Livestock: The Money Behind the National Animal Identification System. Washington, D.C., Food and Water Watch. July 2009.

6.Mellon, M., Benbrook, Charles, Benbrook, Karen Lutz (2001). Hogging It: Estimates of Antimicrobial Abuse in Livestock. Cambridge, MA, Union of Concerned Scientists. January 2001.

7.Kristof, N. (2009). Our Pigs, Our Food, Our Health. The New York Times. New York, New York. March 11, 2009.

* This sentence was edited on 5/7/10 to more accurately reflect our views.


Your thoughtful comments are encouraged, but all comments are held for moderation to protect against spam. Farm Aid does not censor or refuse comments for content unless they are spam or a personal attack.


A New Farm Economy Rises from Tobacco’s Ashes - August, 2014

10 Things the New Census of Agriculture Tells Us About Family Farmers and Our Food System - July 2014

How will the Keystone XL pipeline affect our farmers and farmland? - April, 2014

Parched: What the West shows us about our water future - March, 2014

What does Farm Aid do with the money that it raises at the annual concert? - October 2013

I live in New York and dairy farmers seem to be struggling. What can I do to help? - September 2013

I have heard horror stories about the dead zone in the Gulf of Mexico this year. How can farmers better support our waterways? - July 2013

I finally got around to watching "Food, Inc." I was floored to see what poultry producers actually go through. Is this really what's behind the chicken on my plate? - May 2013

Why is it so difficult for farmers to find affordable farmland these days? - March 2013

The PBS documentary about the Dust Bowl was amazing – what a disaster of epic proportions and a reminder of how important the soil is to our lives! How do today’s farmers care for the soil? - November 2012

The other day, I came across "grassfed beef" in the supermarket. Aren't all beef cattle fed grass? If not, what do they eat? Is this something I should feed my family? - October 2012

How do I find a university that values family farmers and the Good Food Movement? - September 2012

I'm a big supporter of organic agriculture, but some of my friends say it isn't a practical way to feed the world. Is that true? - August 2012

How does someone with no experience get into farming? - August 2012

How is climate change affecting family farmers? What are they doing about it? - April 2012

Is the USDA truly supporting local and regional agriculture?  - March 2012

I'm concerned about the use of antibiotics in farm animals and would like to find antibiotic-free meat and poultry products. Any suggestions? - February 2012

How does the occupy movement relate to farmers? - January 2012

What can you tell me about family farm turkey? - November 2011

How will labeling genetically engineered food do anything for family farmers? - October 2011

Word is big cuts are in store for farmers in the upcoming Farm Bill. What is the Farm Bill and what will budget cuts mean for family farmers? - September 2011

I've been seeing a lot of farm plots spring up around the city. I didn't even realize people could farm in cities—how can I get involved in this! - August 2011

This year’s weather has been a nightmare and lots of farms in my area are struggling. What help is there available for farmers struck by disaster? - July 2011

I watched "Food, Inc." recently and was surprised by how animals were treated and meat was produced in America. This seems crazy to me. Why can’t we get meat from better sources? - June 2011

A lot of farmers in my area are leasing their land for hydraulic fracturing — is it good or bad? What do farmers say? - June 2011

What's a food hub? How can they help me? - April 2011

High farm prices are in the news — are farmers getting rich? - March 2011

I know the U.S. government just allowed a few new GE crops on the market — should I be worried? - February 2011

How can I find food from local farmers during the cold winter months? - January 2011

A year-in-review on corporate concentration in agriculture. - November 2010

Can you tell me about starting farm to school programs? I’m a farmer and I’d love to provide schools in my area with healthy food. - October 2010

No offense, but what has Farm Aid really done all these years aside from put on a good concert? - September 2010

I really want to get local meats, but they don't seem to be available. Why is that? - August 2010

Answering reader questions with our report, "Rebuilding America’s Economy with Family Farm-Centered Food Systems" - July 2010

I just read an article that anticipates 200 dairies will go under in my state by the end of 2010. Why are dairy farmers in so much trouble right now? - June 2010

How is credit affecting family farmers right now? - May 2010

What exactly is a family farm? How does it differ from a factory farm? - April 2010

What's up with food safety? Could new laws hurt family farmers? - March 2010

How can a food system that offers so much variety be constricting consumer choice? - February 2010

I keep hearing about "concentration" in farming. What does that mean and how does it affect me?  - January 2010

What’s Farm Aid’s grant program all about? Where does all the money go? - December 2009

Why are you thankful for family farmers? The Farm Aid staff responds. - November 2009

What are some ways people can get involved in farm activism? - October 2009

I've been seeing a lot of interest lately in seed saving. It seems like a lot of work, why bother? - September 2009

Are factory farms still a threat to America’s family farmers? - August 2009

Do you have any tips for how to fit a farmers market into my busy life? - July 2009

What’s the best way to get more farm fresh food into my child’s school cafeteria? - June 2009

How do I get involved in the dairy crisis at the grassroots level? - May 2009

How can we fix the food safety system without hurting family farmers? - April 2009

How exactly are GE crops regulated? And how can I be sure that I am protected? - March 2009

Dairy farmers are struggling for survival right now - why? - February 2009

Is there a reason why Farm Aid doesn’t grant more to individual farmers? - January 2009

How is the credit crisis affecting farmers and agriculture in America? - December 2008

What does the change in administration mean for family farmers? - November 2008

Where do John McCain and Barack Obama stand on agricultural issues? - October 2008

Does Farm Aid know of any programs that help young people start their own farm? - September 2008

Just how does Farm Aid decide where to host the show each year? - August 2008

Laura looks back on three years answering your questions - July 2008

I try to buy local and from family farmers whenever possible. Why is it so hard to find meat from area farmers? - June 2008

How do you decide who is and isn’t a family farmer? How many family farmers are there in the United States? - May 2008

I see raw milk from time to time at my local grocery, some folks say it’s good –others say its dangerous- what’s the deal? - April 2008

I seem to be spending more and more at the grocery store these days. Is it true that corn prices and ethanol are making my food cost more? - March 2008

I feel like I used to see a lot more in the news about GMOs. I haven’t managed to keep up to date and now I’m not really even sure what’s out there. Could you give me a little update on GMOs? - February 2008

What’s going on with the Farm Bill? Didn’t it pass recently? Is there anything good for family farmers in it? - January 2008

What do farmers do in the winter? - December 2007

What are you serving for Thanksgiving? - November 2007

How did Farm Aid replace the typical concert foods at Farm Aid 2007 and what were the criteria? - October 2007

What do Farm Aid folks do during the winter? - September 2007

Can you suggest some ways to drink locally or seasonally? - August 2007

Is it legal and humane to keep chickens in the city? - July 2007

Is it possible to compost in the city? - June 2007

Should everyone who wants to lessen their impact on the environment consider giving up meat? - May 2007

Can you suggest farm related activities for kids to do? - April 2007

Am I supporting family farmers when I purchase a product labeled organic? - March 2007

Can you help me simplify my food shopping in a way that still supports my values? - February 2007

What New Year's resolutions can I make that will support family farmers? - January 2007

How does Farm Aid help family farmers, where does the money go? - December 2006

How can I find a family farm turkey for Thanksgiving? - November 2006

Is it possible to shop locally on a budget? - October 2006

Why can't I get any of this "delicious food from family farmers" at the Farm Aid concert? - September 2006

Do you have any advice for developing classroom activities involving good food? - August 2006

Who are the farmers in the United States? - July 2006

What kind of work is Farm Aid doing with biodiesel? - June 2006

When will tomatoes be available in farmers markets? - May 2006

Are factory farm birds safer than outdoor birds? - April 2006

Could you tell me a little about the food in New Orleans today? Can you even get local foods in the city? - March 2006

What is biodynamic farming? - February 2006

Why do different companies promote different kinds of pasteurization for milk? - January 2006

How can I eat seasonally year-round if nothing is growing in my area? - December 2005

With all of the devastating elements that farmers have to face, who can help them when a disaster comes? - November 2005

Why is it so hard to find fresh, locally grown produce in my area of Staten Island, NY? - October 2005

What is a "family farm food system"? - June 2005

How can I find a farm near me? - May 2005

What does April on the farm mean in different states? - April 2005

Who are the corporate players in the meat industry? - March 2005

What questions can I ask my grocer? - February 2005

An Introduction to Ask Laura - January 2005

What is grass roots organizing? - August 2005

Where does school food come from? - July 2005



Comments:
Anonymous @ 3/26/2010 6:11:58 AM 
You should try to make Michelle Obama aware of this problem. She should be a more effective advocate for safe, healthy, and local food. She's started but should team up with you on the broader legislative threats to sustainable farmers.
Anonymous @ 3/26/2010 6:25:00 AM 
I approve of this. Growers large and small can put profit ahead of safety. This is a temptation for small growers who might not survive unusual weather conditions or other adverse economic conditions. The larger ones may not care. The consumer has no idea what goes on to get their food harvested. I just produce forage for animals but I have seen what my neighbors do to get a similar crop during the droughts and the dumping of enormous amounts of commercial fertilizers when it finally does rain can't be healthy - I know it has fouled the wells in the area. It is a complicated issue and all the players need to be at the table.
Anonymous @ 3/26/2010 8:04:56 AM 
What about HR 2749? This is a bill passed by the house excludes large corporate farming and comes down squarly on family farms and farmer's markets. this article is very lofty and blindly hopeful, the laws on the floor are geared to burden the people and give more advantage to coporations. National food borne illness come from corporat farming, not small family farms; these laws do not reflect that. "Perscribed practices" is the end of "organic farming". The first of thses bills, HR 875, which is very much like HR2749 was proposed by Delao whose husband has proffessional ties to Monsanto. This is not a soap opera, its the beninning of Food Regulation and you should be greatly concerned
Anonymous @ 3/26/2010 11:25:04 AM 
I am greatly concerned about the ways these laws that purportedly will help small farmers may actually put them out of business.
I am writing a grant that, if funded, will provide some help to farmers in our state (Missouri) to get training which will enable them to fulfill the sometimes onerous requirements of the food safety bills and the Access to Pasture regulations.
It is so important to remember that all of the serious food contaminations have occurred in large CAFOs and processing facilities. The vast majority of family farmers have good agricultural practice and good traceability without government intervention. I can't stress enough how important it is to let your Congresspeople know.
Anonymous @ 4/18/2010 12:27:47 PM 
Kristin Clough Canty's documentary film Farmageddon, should be of interest to FarmAid and those interested in small farms and direct suppliers. A rough cut just screened at the Boston International Film Festival, portraying raw milk suppliers and sheep farmers being raided by a government that looks horrifying unamerican to me. Thanks for supplying the info on the bills that are coming up.
Anonymous @ 4/20/2010 3:00:46 PM 
This is the real threat: GMO foods. Watch these 9 videos.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7qBEt6Z9h9s&feature=related

LISTEN, LEARN, WATCH ON.

Redraw Image


Your comments will not be posted until they have been approved by the moderator.